Paleo Apple Butter French Toast Bake

Nov 4, 2020 | Breakfast

Paleo Apple Butter French Toast Bake–thick slices of grain-free bread coated in apple butter — the perfect make-ahead gluten-free breakfast for a crowd!

Thick slices of grain-free bread coated in apple butter and creamy eggs come together for a delicious Paleo Apple Butter French Toast Bake. The perfect make-ahead gluten-free breakfast for a crowd!

This post is sponsored by Blue Sky Family Farms. All text and opinions are 100% my own. Thank you for continuing to support the brands who help make this blog possible! 

Paleo Apple Butter French Toast Bake

Good morning lovelies! I can’t believe it’s already November and we’re rounding the base to Thanksgiving and Christmas! With this time of year comes the need for more family-friendly brunch recipes that fill up a crowd, so I’m here with an Apple Butter French Toast that will keep everyone happy and full. Because the only thing better than French Toast is a fall-themed version that you don’t have to slave over a stove to make. Oh! And it’s super easy to make gluten or grain-free. A true holiday miracle! I often think about what I miss most about the gluten world. I’d have to go with either waffles or thick, buttery toast at a diner for brunch. (Omg. My mouth is watering hard.) Clearly, breakfast is on my mind (per usual.) Thankfully this Apple Butter French Toast bake fills the comfort-food void with crusty baked bread, sweet apple butter, and maple syrup.

What is a French Toast Bake?

French Toast Bake is exactly what it sounds like: baked French Toast. You need all of the same ingredients as standard french toast, just prepared in bulk and baked. It’s also very similar to bread pudding in the way that you prepare it: You combine everything for your egg mixture, soak your bread, and combine it all in a baking dish and cook until crisp on the edges. I let my bread soak overnight and then cook it the next morning and serve it up with real maple syrup. To keep it paleo I used paleo sandwich bread, but you can also use gluten-free bread or regular bread if it floats your boat!

Pasture-Raised Eggs for French Toast

The more I spend time cooking and learning about ingredients, the more I realize how much of a difference quality makes when it comes to how food tastes and how it makes me feel. I’m buying organic when I can, paying attention to what my food eats, and learning about the more ethical treatment of farm animals. When it comes to eggs I’m always looking for Pasture-Raised on my cartons, which is why I love Blue Sky Family Farms. Pasture-raised chickens are healthier and happier, which means that the eggs they produce are healthier for us. They contain more vitamins (such as D and B-12) and have a healthier Omega ratio, which is especially important if you deal with autoimmunity and hormonal issues like I do. You can see the difference as soon as your crack open the egg and see the rich, deep yolk that looks so much brighter than conventional eggs. My favorite way to cook them is fried or sunny-side-up so I can really taste the delicious, almost buttery-tasting yolk. Of course, they’re also great for recipes like this Apple Butter French Toast and lend a rich flavor and a list of health benefits that you can feel good about serving to your family. Next time you’re at the store be sure to look for the inviting blue packing with Blue Sky Family Farms Eggs. Once you try the rich, velvety eggs you’ll never go back! You can use this store locator to find the stores near you that carry Blue Sky Family Farms.

Tips for making this Paleo Apple Butter French Toast Bake:

  • Use a good, thick bread–not something crumbly. I used a homemade cassava flour bread, but any good gluten-free sandwich bread should be perfect!
  • Give your French Toast adequate time to soak before baking. You’ll want to let it sit for around 8 hours minimum.
  • Watch the top carefully and cover with tinfoil if it starts to burn.
  • Have lots of fresh, real maple syrup on hand for serving!

Without further ado, it’s time to make some delicious French Toast! I’d love to see your beautiful creations so don’t forget to tag me on Instagram or Facebook!

Paleo Apple Butter French Toast Bake

Thick slices of grain-free bread coated in apple butter and creamy eggs come together for a delicious Paleo Apple Butter French Toast Bake. The perfect make-ahead gluten-free breakfast for a crowd!

COURSE Breakfast
Keyword breakfast,, french toast,
PREP TIME 15 minutes
COOK TIME 1 hour
rest 10 hours
TOTAL TIME 11 hours 15 minutes


  • 1 loaf grain-free bread or other
  • 8 Blue Sky Family Farms Pasture Raised Eggs
  • 1 cup full fat coconut milk
  • 1 tsp vanilla
  • 1/4 tsp salt
  • 1 tsp cinnamon
  • 1 cup apple butter


  1. Grease a 9 x 13 pan and set aside.
  2. In a large bowl whisk together eggs, milk, salt, cinnamon, and vanilla together until completely combined.
  3. Slice bread and then cut into half slices. Spread a bit of apple butter on each piece and arrange in the baking dish. Pour the egg mixture evenly over the bread, cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate overnight.

  4. The next morning (or 8-10 hours later) preheat the oven to 350°F. Bake the french toast for about 30 minutes, then cover with tinfoil and bake for an additional 15 minutes.

  5. Brush the remaining apple butter evenly over the top of the french toast. Place back in the oven and bake for 4-10 more minutes.

  6. Allow to cool and then slice and enjoy! Top with maple syrup if desired.

Apple Butter French Toast Bake

Apple Butter French Toast Bake

This post may contain affiliate links, which means I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products that I trust and use myself. Thank you for your support!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Hey! I’m Moriah– a commercial and editorial food photographer and creative entrepreneur who is perpetually drinking coffee and covered in dog hair. I write this blog from New York City where I run my creative agency, The B Edit. I write this blog in the hopes that you can one day have your creative dream job, too!   

Pin It on Pinterest